Monday, October 30, 2023

The Advent of Digital Twins: Should They Replace Caregivers?

 

It's 2027, and your father is in a rest home suffering from Alzheimer's disease.  You are considering a new service that takes samples of your voice and videoclips of you, and creates a highly realistic 3-D "digital twin" that your father can talk with on a screen any time he wants to.  The digital twin has your voice and mannerisms, and shows up on your father's phone to remind him to take his medicine and furnish what the company offering the service calls "companionship."  In the meantime, you yourself can simply go about your own life without having to do the largely tedious work of getting your father to take care of himself. 

 

Should you go ahead and pay for this service?  Or should you just continue with your daily visits to him, visits that are becoming increasingly inconvenient?

 

I put this scenario a few years in the future, but already academics are considering the ethical implications of using digital twins in healthcare.  Matthias Braun, an ethicist at the Friedrich-Alexander University in Germany, thinks that the answer to this question depends on the issue of how much control the original of the twin exerts over it.  Applying that notion to the situation I just outlined, who is involved, and what benefits and harms could result?

 

The people involved are you, your father, and the organization providing the digital twin.  Digital twins are not people—they are software, so while the digital twin is at the core of the issue, it has no ethical rights or responsibilities of its own. 

 

Consider your father first.  It may be that his mind is so fogged by Alzheimer's disease that he may be completely fooled into thinking he is talking on the phone with and watching you, when in fact he's speaking with a sophisticated piece of software.  So by means of the digital twin, your father may well be persuaded to believe something that is not objectively true. 

 

But people who deal with Alzheimer's patients know that sometimes the truth has to be at least elided, if not downright falsified.  When my wife's father with dementia lived with us, he would often ask, "Where's your mother?"  His wife had died some years previously.  An answer like, "She's not here right now," doesn't strictly violate the truth, but leaves an impression that is false.  Nevertheless, it's likely to be a less disruptive reply than something like, "You dummy!  Don't you remember she died in 2007?"

 

Then consider you.  One alternative to providing the digital twin is to hire a full-time personal caregiver, as some people can afford to do.  Besides the expense, there is the question of whether your father will get along with such a person.  While my father-in-law was with us, we tried hiring a caregiver for limited times so that my wife and I could get a few hours' break from continuous 24-hour caregiving.  Unfortunately, the caregiver—an older man—didn't appeal to his patient, and after one such visit we got an earful of complaints about "that guy," and it didn't work out.  So in addition to being expensive, personal caregivers don't always do the job the way you hoped they would.

 

From your perspective, the digital-twin caregiver has the advantage that if successful, your father will think he is really talking with a very familiar person, and is more likely to follow instructions than if a stranger is dealing with him.

 

So where's the harm?  What could possibly go wrong?

 

Consider hacking.  No computer system is 100% secure, and the opportunities for mischief ranging from random meddling to theft and murder are obviously present if someone managed to gain control of the digital twin's software.  It wouldn't be easy, but a lot of very difficult hacks have been carried out by criminals in the past, and if the motivation is there, they will find a way sooner or later. 

 

Even if criminals aren't interested in messing with digital-twin rest-home caregivers, what if your father starts to like the digital twin more than he likes your real physical presence?  After all, a digital twin could be programmed to have nearly infinite patience in dealing with the repeated questions that dementia patients often ask—"Where's your mother?" being a prime example.  How would you feel if you visit your father some day and he says, "I like you a lot better on the screen than I like you now."? 

 

And even if the digital twin doesn't manage to alienate you, the original of its copy, I can't rid myself of a feeling of distaste that if the twin succeeds in fooling your father into thinking it's really you, a species of fraud has been committed.

 

At a minimum, even a successful digital-twin substitution would mean that once again in our digital world, an "I-thou" relationship, in Martin Buber's terms, has been replaced by an "I-it" relationship.  Instead of continuing one of the most meaningful relationships anyone can have in this life—the relationship with one's father—that relationship would be replaced by one that connects your father to a machine.  Yes, a sophisticated machine, a machine that tricks him into thinking he's talking with you, but a machine nonetheless.  In the greater scheme of things, and even leaving religious considerations aside, it's hard to believe that both you and your father would be ultimately better off if your father spent his days talking with a computer and you went about whatever other business you have instead of spending time with him. 

 

Digital twins are not yet so thick on the ground that we have to deal with them as a routine thing—not yet.  But if the momentum of generative AI keeps up its current pace, it is only a matter of time before they will be a genuine option, and we'll have to decide whether to use them, not only in a medical context but in many others as well.  We should sort out what is right and wrong about their use now, before it's too late.

 

Sources:  Matthias Braun's article "Represent me: please! Towards an ethics of digital twins in medicine"  appeared in 2021 in the Journal of Medical Ethics, vol. 47, pp. 394-400. 

Monday, October 23, 2023

Carbon Indulgences: The South Pole Scandal

 

Repentance is hard.  Obtaining true forgiveness is even harder.  So it is no surprise that over the ages, people have tried to find shortcuts around the difficult chores of changing one's ways and being forgiven for going astray.  This week's New Yorker carries the story of one such effort:  the activities of the world's largest carbon-offsetting firm, South Pole, turn out to have been something of a shell game.

 

Carbon offsetting is based on the notion, accepted as gospel in many circles, that by using fossil fuels, humans are committing slow mass suicide that can be averted only by striving toward "net zero"—that is, not adding any more CO2 to the atmosphere than we take out.  A logical consequence of this notion is that doing anything that produces CO2 is the secular equivalent of a sin in Christian theology.  Unfortunately, this type of sinning is extremely hard to avoid, because ordinary things like turning on the lights, driving a car, flying, or running a business—especially a manufacturing business—necessitate committing manifold sins of this kind. 

 

As in the days of old when people sought out Catholic priests to get their sins absolved, people and corporations today want to get the same feeling of being washed clean of their carbon misdeeds, but without facing the hard tasks of doing without fossil fuels altogether.

 

Enter South Pole, and smaller outfits like them.  South Pole sells "carbon offsets."  The basic idea is simple:  if you want to make up for your carbon sins, conveniently measured in millions of tons of CO2, you simply pay South Pole the going rate, which has varied widely over the years like any other commodity.  And voila!—South Pole promises to preserve a Zimbabwean forest that would otherwise be cut down, and those precious trees will absorb not only your carbon sins, but those of all the other companies paying millions for carbon offsets.

 

Deforestation is another secular sin we've heard a lot about, so it makes a certain amount of sense to pay villagers not to cut down trees.  That's fine as long as the villagers really do refrain from destroying the forest, and also if it was certain that they would have cut it down otherwise.  You can already see a potential problem here, involving long-term hypotheticals.  How sure are we that the forest in question would have been destroyed if the offset money wasn't paid?  And how sure can we be that most of the money is really getting to the villagers whose behavior has to change?

 

Not so sure, it turns out.  Heidi Blake's article describes in great detail the dubious accounting of one Steve Wentzel, who was South Pole's man in Zimbabwe charged with actually implementing the forest preservation.  According to Blake, Wentzel promised a great deal more than he delivered.  While he still claims to have prevented the requisite amount of deforestation, he has no paper trail to prove it, and says that the erratic Zimbabwean economy and currency forced him to do what amounted to money-laundering in order to get U. S. currency with which to pay the villagers. 

 

Blake describes how one employee after another of South Pole left the organization once they realized that the firm was taking money mainly to make its customers feel better, not because they were doing anything objectively to improve the world's climate crisis.    In addition, the price of carbon offsets has gyrated wildly in recent years, affected by such things as the failure of the Kyoto Protocol agreement to commit most major carbon-emitting countries to substantial reductions. 

 

This situation reminds me of an episode in the Protestant Reformation that involved what are called indulgences.  In order to be fair to the Catholic side, I'm going to quote directly from the Catholic Encyclopedia (published around 1914) as to what an indulgence is:  "An indulgence is the extra-sacramental remission of the temporal punishment due, in God's justice, to sin that has been forgiven, which remission is granted by the Church in the exercise of the power of the keys, through the application of the superabundant merits of Christ and of the saints, and for some just and reasonable motive."  Preceding that is a definition of what an indulgence is not, which includes the following:  "It is not a permission to commit sin, nor a pardon of future sin; . . . [i]t is not the forgiveness of the guilt of sin . . . . "

 

The basic idea, as this Protestant understands it, is this.  Only God through Jesus Christ's atonement really forgives sins.  But even if a sin is forgiven, there remains "temporal punishment," meaning that souls who have died without being fully cleansed of their venial sins have to undergo some suffering in Purgatory before going to Heaven.  And, according to Catholic doctrine, prayers and good works by the living on behalf of those suffering in Purgatory can help them get out sooner than otherwise.

 

In the 16th century, someone (it isn't clear who) came up with the following jingle in Germany:  "Sobald der Pfenning im Kasten klingt, die Selle aus dem Fegfeuer springt."  In English:  "As soon as the coin in the coffer rings, the soul out of purgatory springs."  In other words, if you give me money, I can guarantee your Aunt Bertha will get out of Purgatory.  It was associated with one Johann Tetzel, who apparently preached in the spirit of such a saying without using the actual words. 

 

The misuse of indulgences was one of the inspirations for the Protestant Reformation, and although the Church still offers indulgences, it no longer puts a price on them. 

 

South Pole appears to be a modern-day secular equivalent of Johann Tetzel, promising more than it can possibly deliver.  But in a free market, the price of forgiveness can soar, and those who trade in it can profit mightily.  What they do with the money is another question.  The carbon-offset concept seems so inherently open to abuse that I, for one, think it should be abandoned for more practical short-term efforts to deal with the consequences of climate change.  But there will always be those seeking secular forgiveness, and those willing to sell it for a good price.

 

Sources:  Heidi Blake's article "Hot Air" appears on pp. 42-55 of the Oct. 23, 2023 issue of The New Yorker.  I found the German version of Tetzel's non-quote at James Swan's blog https://beggarsallreformation.blogspot.com/2012/01/did-tetzel-really-say-as-soon-as-coin.html, and referred to the online Catholic Encyclopedia definition of indulgence at https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07783a.htm.

Monday, October 16, 2023

Don't Bet on Online Gambling

 

Headlines aren't supposed to be in the imperative mood, telling readers what to do.  But in this case I think it's appropriate.  Online gambling in many U. S. states has become a multibillion-dollar industry.  While many people can control their gambling, others can't.  And the ones who can't are suffering, along with their families and friends.

 

Full disclosure:  I don't personally gamble, I have little interest in sports, and my state of residence (Texas) does not allow sports gambling, either in person or online.  So mine is definitely an outsider's viewpoint, but perhaps that can make me more objective. 

 

In 1992, the U. S. Congress passed the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA) which prohibited sports gambling in all U. S. states and territories, with some minor exceptions.  Over the next decade, individual states where gambling was popular, notably New Jersey, mounted legal challenges to the act, and in 2018 the Supreme Court ruled that it was an unconstitutional violation of states' rights, citing the Tenth Amendment to the Constitution. 

 

This opened the door for individual states to allow sports gambling, and so far about half of them have in one form or another. 

 

In the time PASPA was in force, the United Kingdom legalized sports betting and became one of the early hotspots for online gambling with the advent of smart phones.  According to an article in the Financial Times, in recent years a spate of bad publicity and suicides related to gambling addiction has led to a crackdown on online gambling.  Since 2017, UK online gambling organizations have paid fines of about $240 million in fines to that country's gambling regulatory agency.

 

Like any addiction, online gambling is easy to fall into and hard to escape the clutches of.  The Financial Times article tells the story of 22-year-old Dylan, a New Jersey lawyer in training who recently confessed to his family that he had spent over $50,000 in mostly online bets.  He is currently attending Gamblers Anonymous and hopes to free himself from his addiction, but unless he divests himself of his cellphone and stays away from computers, the means to resume it will always be literally at hand.

Ethically speaking, gambling is an activity in which one person—the gambler—risks something of value, and another person or entity, which we will call "the house" profits from the gambler's risks, on average over time.  Gambling is distinguished from stealing because presumably, the gambler receives something of value from the activity.  And unlike armed robbery, whose victims generally have no choice in the matter, nobody is obliged to gamble.  In this regard, a libertarian would in principle oppose any attempts to regulate gambling, saying that unless some third party is harmed by the transaction, the gambler and the house should be left alone.

 

There is also the argument that casinos and other forms of gambling benefit certain communities.  This was the idea behind allowing certain Indian tribes to run casinos in the U. S.  While nobody can deny that such things make money, I can't shake an uneasy feeling that basing a particular cultural group's economic viability on such a foundation is not in the best interests of the group, or their customers either, for that matter.

 

And gambling doesn't take money from all socioeconomic groups equally, either.  Many studies have shown that gambling revenues are regressive, in the sense that most of the money comes from the poorer segments of the population—those who can least afford it, in other words.  The libertarian would come along and say, "Well, if those folks choose to spend their money that way, it's their choice, and who are you to interfere?" 

 

One way to look at an economic activity is to ask what would happen if a whole lot of people tried to make money that way.  I'm not a trained economist, but it's worth a try, anyway.  Clearly, gambling is a parasite on any economy worthy of the name.  If everybody tried to make money by gambling, no one would have any time left to do anything productive.  The economy would devolve into the equivalent of prisoners playing pinochle for toothpicks.  It might pass the time, but it's not going to put food in anyone's mouth or make anything useful.

 

Granted, we are not in imminent danger of turning into a nation of 24-hour gamblers.  But online gambling is particularly pernicious because it produces a complete geographic separation between the gambler and where his or her money ultimately ends up.  In a friendly office football pool, you at least know the people who end up with your money if you lose.  Betting on your football team online may enrich some executives in the Cayman Islands, but it's a net loss to your neighborhood. 

 

Of course, many states (including Texas) run lotteries, which is a sort of gambling monopoly exercised by the state involved.  And because I teach at a state university, some portion of my paycheck could probably be traced to revenues from the state lottery.  I wish it were otherwise, because I disapprove of gambling in general, but not so much that I'm going to quit my job over it.  This is really just an example of how an industry can co-opt government into benefiting from its operations, even if on balance those operations are harmful to the public.

 

It's interesting that Richard Daynard, who is a professor of law at Northeastern University, is now looking into filing a class-action lawsuit against online gambling outfits, claiming that their advertisements are misleading and that they encourage problem gamblers to go deeper into their addiction.  The online betting industry had better pay attention to what Prof. Daynard is doing, because he was one of the prime movers behind the giant settlement with the tobacco industry that took $200 billion out of their collective hides for deceptive advertising.  After that lawsuit, you didn't see any more ads with doctors in white coats saying how healthy X cigarette was for you.  So if you're invested in online gambling, you might try to find some other way to make money—or lose it.

 

Sources:  The Financial Times article "The Dark Side of the U. S. Sports Betting Boom" by Oliver Barnes appeared on Aug. 9, 2023 at https://www.ft.com/content/2e1a235a-8a46-47f3-b040-5ca21a04ebf4.  I also referred to Wikipedia's article on PASPA.

 

Monday, October 09, 2023

Irony in Orlando: Men Gate-Crash Grace Hopper Job Fair

 

For the last three decades, one of the biggest job fairs for women in tech has been the Grace Hopper Celebration, named after the computer-science pioneer who devised the theory of machine-independent programming languages.  In the past, the fair has been a Mecca of sorts for women looking for high-tech jobs, and not surprisingly, the great majority of attendees have been women, or lately "non-binary" persons as well, according to a news report in Wired. 

 

This year's GHC held in Orlando, Florida was a disappointment to many women, however.  The problem?  In a word, men.

 

Lots of high-tech companies have laid off their skilled help in the last couple of years, and so there is a larger than usual turnover in the field, with people of both sexes trying to find jobs.  By Federal law, GHC cannot discriminate against men by, for example, allowing only women (and non-binaries) to attend.  So technically, it has always been open to men, but everybody involved knew that the main idea was to provide a place where women (and non-binaries) could gain the exclusive attention of recruiters, and recruiters could count on being able to make their upper management happy by hiring more women.  But this year, not so much.

 

If anyone kept statistics on the number of men and number of women (and non-binaries), the Wired reporter, Amanda Hoover, didn't cite them.  The most she could get out of a conference organizer was that there was "an increase in participation of self-identifying males."  Clearly, there were more men than many women wanted to see there.  A founder of a "female-talent focused media platform" said she heard from a number of women who were sad and frustrated.  A female student from Ohio State said, "Now is one of the most important times to advocate for gender equity."   

 

Consider that phrase "gender equity."  The word "equity" has chased "equality" out of rights-based public discourse like bad money chases good out of circulation.  That is not to make a iniquitous judgment against equity.  But some people use the word "equity" to mean a goal that seeks something close to identical outcomes, not just equal opportunities for everyone.

 

Here's an example from my own field of engineering.  Prior to about 1960, a woman who wished to become a professional engineer faced tremendous obstacles which were social, legal, and customary in nature.  Many engineering schools accepted only men.  The ones who accepted women sometimes didn't allow them to take certain courses or specializations.  If a woman managed to get a degree and an engineering job, she was almost certain in a meeting to be asked to go get the coffee, as I heard from a pioneering civil engineer who also happened to be female. 

The field of engineering, in the U. S., anyway, lacked both equality and equity for women.

 

Following the enactment of various civil-rights laws and the advance of feminism in the 1960s, most of the formal legal and organizational barriers that kept women out of engineering collapsed.  Women could take any engineering course or degree, and many did.  As time went on, they went from being a tiny and obvious minority to being relatively common in the field, and in a generation some rose to positions of management, founders, and so on.  Most people would agree that equality has been achieved for women in engineering, by and large.

 

But what about equity?  Many government officials, politicians, and activists who concern themselves with such things keep their eyes on the raw numbers of women in this or that field, and compare that number with the magic 51.1%  What is magic about 51.1%?  That is the fraction of the U. S. population who are female.  If the percentage of women in any field whatsoever—engineering, law, medicine, harness racing—is less than 51.1%, to these folks that is ipso facto evidence that equity has not been achieved.  Hence the billions of dollars expended by the U. S. National Science Foundation on programs for women in engineering, and other perpetual efforts to bring the fraction of women in engineering schools and organizations closer to that magic number.

 

So far, it hasn't worked, at least in the U. S.  Those of us who believe that there are deep-seated psychological as well as physical differences between men and women (and non-binaries), which may lead the two sexes to choose different kinds of careers for reasons that may be obscure even to themselves, are not overly troubled by this fact.  I rejoice that the barriers to equality came down.  I find it easier to remember the names of the women in my classes, not solely because there are only a few of them, but I'm sure it helps.  But I don't think it is a blot on the escutcheon of engineering that we have fewer than 51.1% women in the field, any more than I think it is a shame that there are less than 51.1% of men teaching kindergarten classes. 

 

The irony of a womens' tech job fair being overrun by men is this.  The same law that allowed women to do engineering at all, allows men to go to job fairs designed mainly for women.  So when men take advantage of a privilege that women have benefited from, the women get annoyed. 

 

I personally don't see why the organizers of the GHC can't declare it a private club for four days and admit only people they like, whether they be women, non-binary, red-headed, or whatever.  If women (and non-binaries) want to have a meeting to themselves, by all means let them have it.  Surely their lawyers could find a way to do this.  But it would smack of the old private-club dodge that Southern swimming pools tried for a while to exclude blacks, until the lawyers put a stop to that.  So maybe it wouldn't work after all.

 

The best outcome of all would be if men, out of deference to womens' delicate feelings, and acting as true gentlemen, refrained from registering for the GHC next year, and let the women know the reason they were staying away.  But that would probably just make them even madder.

 

Sources:  Amanda Hoover's article "Men Overran a Job Fair Designed for Women in Tech" appeared on the Wired website at https://www.wired.com/story/grace-hopper-celebration-career-fair-men/.  I also referred to the Wikipedia article on Grace Hopper.

Monday, October 02, 2023

A Fatal Ammonia-Tanker Crash in Illinois

 

Around 5 p. m. on Friday, Sept. 29, a wreck on Interstate 70 between Effingham and Teutopolis, Illinois caused authorities to divert traffic from the interstate onto the older Route 40 that goes directly through the two towns.  Farming is the main business in that region, and among the vehicles diverted onto Route 40 that evening was a tanker truck carrying 7,500 gallons of anhydrous ammonia, which is a popular form of nitrogen fertilizer.

 

At 9:25 p. m., the truck overturned in a multiple-vehicle collision which is still being investigated by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB).  Because of the large toxic plume of ammonia that resulted, first responders evacuated about 500 people from northeast Teutopolis overnight, allowing them to return late Saturday.  Once rescuers were able to access the scene, it was found that five people had died, including two children under 12.  It was not clear at this writing whether the victims died of ammonia inhalation or from effects of the crash itself, but five survivors were taken to a local hospital as well.

 

Every day, hundreds of ammonia tankers travel between distribution points on their way to supplying farmers with what many consider to be an essential and economical fertilizer.  Ammonia gas, which consists of one atom of nitrogen and three of hydrogen, is a colorless acrid-smelling substance that boils at 28 below zero Fahrenheit.  (The household bottles of ammonia that can be found in grocery stores are actually weak solutions of the gas in water.)  Before Fritz Haber developed a high-pressure process to synthesize ammonia directly from hydrogen and nitrogen in the air around 1910, ammonia was obtained mainly by distilling animal urine, a messy and expensive job at best.  After World War II-era chemical plants found themselves with an overcapacity of ammonia plants once the war ended, the price dropped to the point that direct injection of the gas into soil at a depth of six inches or more became a fast and economical means of applying nitrogen fertilizer.  Since then, an entire anhydrous-ammonia infrastructure has grown up to deliver the substance to millions of acres of farmland, usually without incident.

 

But every now and then something goes wrong, as it did last week in Teutopolis.  Despite the best efforts of mechanical designers to make tanker trucks safe, collisions can sever connecting pipes and cause leaks, which is apparently what happened last Friday.  Ammonia as a gas is lighter than air, but if enough is released near the ground it will form a suffocating cloud that cannot be seen.  This is why the authorities took the prudent precaution of evacuating part of Teutopolis once the nature of the accident became clear. 

 

In addition to being toxic at concentrations above a few parts per million, ammonia is explosive when present at air concentrations higher than about 15%.  So if you escape being suffocated by it, you could instead be blown to bits. 

 

It's surprising that there aren't more accidents involving anhydrous ammonia, but when it is used in properly designed equipment by trained operators who know how dangerous it is, it can be transported safely all the way from the factory to the soil, where it is quickly absorbed by complex chemicals and biological materials and becomes available to fuel plant growth. 

 

At the same time, it is a highly unnatural process characterized by many features that we associate with modern industrial culture:  large-scale concentrations of products, complex distribution networks, and use in largely monoculture farms (all corn or all wheat, for example).  All these things go against the grain (so to speak) of the small-farming idea that each farm should be its own ecosystem, recycling manure to the soil, which grows the food for the animals, and so on. 

 

For whatever reason, we as a culture seem to be happy with (or at least blissfully unaware of) the forces and compromises involved in the kind of industrial-scale agriculture that we have.  The cheapest food, if externalities such as ammonia accidents are ignored, will always be the mass-produced type made with the minimum amount of labor using the largest economies of scale.  But externalities are not nothing, and the problems that large-scale agriculture causes, ranging from pollution to alleged animal cruelty to obesity, don't often have dollar prices attached to them. 

 

If we were losing hundreds of people a year in anhydrous-ammonia accidents, the issue might come into public consciousness to the extent that some might at least question the propriety of fertilizing plants this way.  But as it is, such mishaps are so unusual as to be newsworthy in themselves.  While it is tragic any time anybody is killed, we may find that the people who lost their lives in this accident were killed by the consequences of the collision itself and not the ammonia that was released afterwards.  Either way, it seems that we as a nation are willing to accept some hazards—namely, having tons of anhydrous ammonia rolling around on highways and railroads—in exchange for the advantages that the process confers on farming.

 

I recently read a book with a title that my wife remarked was one of the longest for a non-fiction book she's seen:  The End is Near And It's Going To Be Awesome:  How Going Broke Will Leave America Richer, Happier, and More Secure.  Its author, Kevin Williamson, has a background in economics, but he's not one of these wonky numbers-only types who reduces every human to a rational utility optimizer.  His main point is that when society wants to do something, the best way to do it is for interested people to get together and figure it out for themselves.  Only as a last resort should we invoke the power of politics to pass laws about the issue.  The reason is that law is a blunt instrument that is usually wielded by the powerful to exploit the less powerful, and no matter how well-intended the action is to start with, the effect usually ends up making the strong better off at the expense of the less fortunate.

 

So while we await the results of the Teutopolis accident investigation, let's hope it doesn't lead to a call for new regulations on the anhydrous-ammonia industry.  From all appearances, that enterprise seems to be handling things pretty well on its own, and I hope the tank-truck makers learn from this accident how to prevent more like it in the future.

 

Sources:  I referred to articles on the Teutopolis accident at https://www.cnn.com/2023/09/30/us/illinois-anhydrous-ammonia-leak/index.html

and https://abc7chicago.com/teutopolis-fatal-crash-evacuation-anhydrous-leak-ammonia/13847580/.  Kevin D. Williamson's The End is Near And It's Going To Be Awesome was published in 2013 by HarperCollins.

Monday, September 25, 2023

Unintended Consequences: The California Electric Truck Mandate

 

If you own a trucking company that picks up shipments from California ports, you now have to deal with the consequences of a new law designed to reduce your carbon footprint.

 

Trucking is one of the vital ingredients in our infrastructure that virtually all parts of the economy rely on.  About two-fifths of all containerized imports to the U. S. come through one of California's twelve commercial ports.  According to a recent report in National Review, beginning January 1, any trucker doing "drayage" (the technical term for transporting stuff to or from a seaport) in California can only buy zero-emission vehicles, although they can hang on to their existing diesel fleet for a while.

 

Trucks don't last forever, however, and evidently the court of wisdom otherwise known as the California legislature decided this was the best way to get truckers used to the additional coming mandate that in 2035, all trucks entering California seaports and intermodal rail yards (where the containers are loaded onto trains) must be zero-emission types. 

 

The ostensible motivation for these laws is to reduce the emission of greenhouse gases, of course.  And careful analyses do show that over the lifetime of an electric vehicle, even if you include the fossil fuels used in the different types of manufacturing (electric versus internal-combustion) and in producing the electricity for the vehicle, less carbon dioxide results from using electric vehicles.  That's the intended consequence, and unless the law is later modified, it will be achieved.

 

But the devil is in the details, and some truckers interviewed about the mandate pointed out several unintended consequences that may follow from these laws.  For one thing, the number of electric trucks in California will have to go from about 300, where it is today, to around 500,000, and some way will have to be found to charge all those trucks, and to keep them running farther than the alleged 60 miles that the California regulators said was the typical drayage daily mileage.  A lot of truckers drive a lot farther than that every day, and if you add several hours a day to charge the trucks, it turns a normal workday into a 20-hour day. 

 

And then there's the cost.  Even if you can find a zero-emission truck that will do the job, it will cost three or four times what a diesel vehicle costs.  And one trucker asked what bank will finance such a purchase if you can't show where you're going to charge it and how you will work out a schedule that will let you stay in business. 

 

So if California doubles down on enforcement, we can anticipate something like a gradual strangling of commerce flowing through its ports as the few truckers who manage to jump through the hoops of regulation are all that's left.  And maybe that was what the lawmakers really wanted anyway.  If the idealist dream of a zero-emission society were to come to pass in the next couple of years, millions would die of starvation and cold, and those few who are left would be reduced to living a life that would be familiar to a denizen of 1880. 

 

At the very least, essentially shutting down 40% of containerized imports to the U. S. would cause massive supply-chain disruptions that would make what happened during COVID look like a hiccup.  If you say no one would let things get that bad, well, we did let things get that bad during COVID, and it can happen again.

 

I recently came across a true story that should become the paradigm cautionary tale for those who close their eyes to the unintended consequences of legislation. 

 

In England in the mid-1800s, dogs were quite commonly used for transportation.  Poor people who couldn't afford a horse and wagon to carry their goods to market could nevertheless use a dog and a "dog-cart" (not to be confused with the horse-drawn carriage referred to in Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes tales).  But in 1841, the recently founded Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA) successfully lobbied to pass a law prohibiting the use of dogs for transportation.  In urging this measure, the SPCA cited a few highly publicized instances of cruelty to transport dogs, although it appears that many if not most of the dogs were well-treated.  For good measure, a dog tax was also passed around the same time, further discouraging the use of dogs for business purposes.

 

I can't be positive, but I suspect that the SPCA members were largely upper-class types who, if they thought ahead at all, imagined all the dogs formerly used for transport would revert to being beloved pets.  Think again.  According to Stanley Coren, a dog psychologist and historian, when the law took effect it led to something close to a dog holocaust:  

 

"Dreadful massacres of dogs took place all over England when they could no longer legally be used for cartage but were now taxable.  In Birmingham, more than a thousand were slaughtered, and similar carnage took place in Liverpool.  In Cambridge, the streets were littered with dead dogs.  Because these bodies were becoming a health hazard, the high constable of Cambridge arranged a mass burial of four hundred dogs."

 

So much for good intentions.  The SPCA survived this debacle somehow, and so did the use of dogs for transportation in other parts of the world, but no longer in England.

 

No one can be certain of exactly what will happen if California enforces their zero-emission truck mandate.  But they are meddling with a piece of infrastructure that is crucial to the entire U. S. economy, and if the law has the unintended consequence of disrupting commerce in ways that harm millions of U. S. citizens, those harms should be weighed against whatever essentially unmeasurable good that may eventually come a century or so after California's greenhouse-gas emissions go down by a few percent as a result of this law.  In my view, the law will do a lot more harm than good, and most of the California truckers think so too.

 

Sources:  National Review's website carried the article "California EV Rules 'Totally Impractical,' Truckers Say; Might as Well 'Build a Spaceship and Go to Mars'" at https://www.nationalreview.com/news/california-ev-rules-totally-impractical-truckers-say-may-as-well-build-a-spaceship-and-go-to-mars/.  I also referred to https://historum.com/t/dog-carts-as-a-form-of-transport.196441/, https://www.carbonbrief.org/factcheck-how-electric-vehicles-help-to-tackle-climate-change/, and Stanley Coren's The Intelligence of Dogs:  Canine Consciousness and Capabilities (Macmillan, 1994), pp. 155-156. 

Monday, September 18, 2023

Is Attribution Science Really Science?

 

A recent issue of Physics Today described a new field called "attribution science" which endeavors to attribute certain extreme weather events to human-caused climate change.  I'm not going to get into the specifics of the particular examples it cites, because they are many and varied.  But I will note that this kind of activity is becoming quite popular, not only in the physics community, but in geosciences as well.  I have read several papers in which the authors make statements like "This Japanese heat wave is virtually certain to have been caused by human-induced climate change."

 

What I would like to examine is the philosophical bona fides of this type of activity.  That is, what is the logical chain, assuming there is one, from the starting premises of such a statement's argument that leads to such disturbing and definite conclusions?

 

To say A is caused by B with some degree of confidence, we can do one of a number of things.  One way to verify such a statement is to take B away and see if A still happens.  Unfortunately, we can't just take another identical Earth, remove most of the carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, and then see how it runs after that.  The experiment we are running with this planet is unique, as far as we know, and so our ability to fiddle with the variables in different experimental runs is nil. 

 

Another way to verify causality is to show that when A happens, B happens shortly afterwards and not when A doesn't happen.  The Physics Today article calls this kind of causality "Granger causality" and says there are statistical methods to predict B happening based on statistics concerning A and B, whatever they might be.  But, as the article points out, this kind of test is subject to the post hoc, propter hoc fallacy (meaning roughly "afterwards, therefore because of").  That is, just because the New York City blackout of 1965 happened right after a kid hit a light pole with a stick doesn't mean that the kid caused the blackout—despite what the terror-stricken kid confessed to his mother when he got home.

 

What the attributionists typically do is to gin up some atmospheric models that produce probabilities of this or that event that they are trying to blame on people.  Then they tinker with the atmosphere's CO2 levels, or concentration of aerosols, or something that is pretty clearly due to human activity.  And then they run their models again to see if they get the same disastrous weather that happened before, or whether leaving the human activity out makes it less likely.

 

The logical problem with this game is that no climate model I know of includes absolutely everything that affects the climate.  They all approximate or ignore certain factors.  So anything claimed for these models can be answered by asking, "Sez who?  And how do you know that something you ignored wouldn't give you different results than you got?"  Logically speaking, there is no defensible reply to that question.

 

I have done some very simple modeling of physical systems, and let me tell you:  it's very easy to get almost anything you want, and the more variables there are, the easier it is to do that.  And I'm not necessarily accusing the parties involved of fraud.  They may be honestly trying to make their models work better, not make them produce the results they want.  But the dividing line between "work better" and "get the results we want" is a thin and permeable one. 

 

After reading several such articles, I start to get the feeling that all pretense of what used to be called objective science has been abandoned.  Everybody knows that if you write a paper using a model that shows Hurricane X was conclusively not caused by HICC, the chances of getting it published are small, to say the least.  All the media, all the funding, and all the scientists, nearly, are predisposed to hear the bad news that we humans are the problem that causes every single bad thing that happens weather-wise. 

 

Was it Mark Twain who said there are lies, damned lies, and statistics?  If so, he was writing at a time when the discipline of statistics was just beginning to be recognized as a new and powerful way of understanding the world.  And don't get me wrong—statistical study is a vitally necessary part of doing big-data science.  It can't be done any other way. 

 

But when sophisticated mathematics, not comprehensible to anyone except a few experts, is brought to bear on the question of whether HICC "caused" a particular adverse weather event—a flood, a fire, a drought, a tornado, a hurricane, you name it—the average layperson is placed at an unfair disadvantage.  If he denies that this is the case, then the scientist will say the layman doesn't know what he's talking about.  And in a sense, that's true.  But even laypeople can understand that the kind of certainty we can have about the sun coming up tomorrow morning is not obtainable when it's a question of complicated and incomplete climate models and highly localized and specific weather events.

 

The Physics Today article said as much, if one bothered to read between the lines, or just the lines themselves.  They addressed several types of attribution science and showed there were serious flaws in each one, although not so severe as to render the enterprise completely worthless.  But I wonder.

 

 Everybody agrees that even if we shut off all fossil-fuel burning tomorrow, we would be stuck with whatever effects our present CO2 levels have for the better part of a century.  It seems to me that scientists would be better employed by looking for ways to mitigate the climate changes we are going to have, rather than disrupting or destroying the world's economy in a fruitless attempt to shut the barn door after the CO2 horse has escaped.

 

Sources:  The September 2023 issue of Physics Today carried the article "Connecting Extreme Weather Events to Climate Change" by Michael Wehner on pp. 40-46.  I also referred to the Wikipedia article on Granger causality.

Monday, September 11, 2023

The Moroccan Earthquake and Building Codes

Last Friday, at 11:11 PM local time, the city of Marrakech in Morocco was hit by a 6.8-magnitude earthquake.  Within a day, the fatality count exceeded 2,000 and continues to rise as this is written (Sunday morning).  Photos from Marrakech and surrounding cities near the Atlas Mountains show cracked and toppled towers and piles of rubble, especially in small villages where enforcement of building codes is lax. 

 

According to an Associated Press report of the disaster, Morocco lies on the intersection of the African and Eurasian tectonic plates.  Earthquakes tend to cluster where plates collide, but compared to some plate-intersection regions, strong earthquakes in northwest Africa are relatively rare.  When they occur, though, they tend to cause massive destruction.  In 1960, a Moroccan earthquake of magnitude 5.8 caused thousands of deaths as well.   

 

As earthquakes go, a magnitude 5.8 event is not the worst possible.  The world's record quake in terms of magnitude was a 9.5-magnitude event along a long fault in Chile in 1960.  Bearing in mind that quake magnitudes are logarithmic—a 6.0-magnitude quake has ten times the amplitude of movement of a 5.0-magnitude one—a magnitude-5.8 quake in the U. S. might not even cause any fatalities, depending on how densely populated the region was and the nature of the buildings involved.  For example, in 1973 the 5.8-magnitude Point Mugu earthquake in Ventura County, California caused several injuries and over $1 million in damage, but no one died as a result.

 

Just quoting the magnitude of an earthquake doesn't tell you everything about how it will affect a given building.  For that, you need something called the modified Mercatili intensity scale.  This scale runs from I (not felt) to XII (third stage of extreme), and why Mercatili chose to use Roman numerals is not known (unless he felt a patriotic need as an Italian to use Roman numerals).  For a given magnitude of quake, there is a maximum Mercatili number it can cause on the surface, because obviously the farther away you are from the epicenter, the less shaking you will experience.  According to Wikipedia, a magnitude-6.8 quake can cause a Mercatili shaking of up to IX (nine, for those unfamiliar with Roman numerals).  This can cause damage even in wood-frame structures, which are much more tolerant of earthquakes than unreinforced masonry and rock buildings.  But typically, such a quake causes only shaking to Mercatili number VII (seven), which according to geophysicist Kelly Martin can be withstood by most small U. S. residential buildings, although with some minor damage but no fatalities.

 

And that is one of the key reasons why Morocco suffered so much damage in last week's magnitude-6.8 quake.  By its nature, masonry not reinforced with steel reinforcement bars ("rebar"), which is a very traditional form of building, is poorly adapted to resist earthquakes.  If the wall or building is basically one heavy block put on top of another with only gravity to hold them down, the tensile stress that occurs when the bottom layer of masonry moves under the huge inertia of the masonry above makes the joints between the blocks fail.  It's not much different than piling up a pile of children's blocks on a towel, and then pulling the towel.  It doesn't take much of a pull to make the whole pile come apart and fall down.

 

That being the case, why don't countries like Morocco enforce building codes so that most structures can withstand a Mercatili shaking of VII or more?  The authorities in Morocco are in the best position to answer that question, but I can speculate.

 

One factor is money, or more specifically, per-capita GDP.  Making a masonry building resistant to earthquakes is not a simple undertaking.  It requires expertise, skilled craftsmen who know how to translate the engineering requirements into reality, and money to pay for extra things like braces, rebar, and other features that will not add anything to the perceived value of the structure unless and until an earthquake occurs. 

 

For numerous reasons, these factors all militate against the likelihood of your average citizen moving into an earthquake-resistant house in a place like Morocco.  If the citizen has a certain amount of money, and one contractor says he can build a 1,500-square-foot place for that amount, and a second contractor says he can build an earthquake-resistant building for the same amount, only it will be 1,000 square feet, well, most people are going to go for the bigger building.  Much has been made about fatalism in Muslim countries, which is allegedly the habit of attributing disaster to God's will.  By my judgment, there is at least as much fatalism in the U. S. concerning disasters, but what we have here is building codes that are actually enforced, plus a tendency not to make houses out of pure masonry, brick, or stone.

 

Asking Moroccans to build wooden houses would be like asking to go waterskiing in Death Valley:  the requisite materials are simply not available.  So why aren't building codes for masonry buildings enforced to make them more resistant to earthquakes?

 

One big problem in very old countries like Morocco is that a lot of the buildings are decades or centuries old.  One famous structure that was damaged in last week's earthquake, Marrakesh's Koutoubia Mosque with a 226-foot-high tower, was built in the 12th century A. D.  It reportedly suffered damage, but the extent is not known and the tower apparently did not fall down.  Even U. S. building codes typically do not require retrofitting of existing structures until they are sold or extensively modified.  If an old structure of importance is judged to be an earthquake hazard in the U. S., more typically it is just torn down and replaced.  But you don't just tear down a historic mosque.

 

Our sympathies are with the survivors of the Moroccan earthquake, who will no doubt plea for the government and King Mohammed VI to do something to prevent such fatalities next time.  But as next time may not be for a long time, it's quite possible that any efforts to improve building codes, or to remedy hazards in existing buildings, may be forgotten before the next major quake comes along.

 

Sources:  I referred to an Associated Press article by Sam Metz and Mosa'ab Elshamy that was carried in the Los Angeles Times at https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2023-09-09/morocco-earthquake-kills-600-damages-historic-buildings.  I also referred to articles at https://www.quora.com/What-magnitude-earthquake-can-an-average-building-withstand,

https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/can-megaquakes-really-happen-magnitude-10-or-larger, and the Wikipedia articles on specific earthquakes mentioned and the modified Mercatili intensity scale.


Monday, September 04, 2023

Electric Vehicle Owners Pay Tax in Texas

 

Last Friday, a new law went into effect that seeks to close a loophole that drivers of electric vehicles have been enjoying:  their freedom from per-gallon road taxes in Texas.  As of Sept. 1, new electric-vehicle (EV) owners will have to pay a $400 first-time registration fee, and $200 annually to renew their registration.  Up to now, EV owners have escaped the twenty-cents-per-gallon state road tax that internal-combustion (IC) vehicle owners pay.  But as Teslas, Chevy Volts, and other less popular EVs show up in increasing numbers, the concern was that these drivers were essentially freeloading on the taxes paid by their fellow drivers who were paying for gas.  Texas now joins 32 other states which have enacted some form of compensatory tax on EVs.

 

It's interesting that if you do the math, you can figure out what kind of gas-guzzling car you'd have to be driving in order for the EV tax to be equivalent to what you would actually pay in state gasoline taxes for your old-fashioned IC car.  Ignoring for a moment the first-time fee, the Texas gasoline tax rate is 0.20 per gallon.  How many gallons do you have to buy per year to pay $200 in state gas taxes?  That's easy—1000 gallons.  Assuming you drive the fairly typical 12,000 miles a year, that means to pay as much tax as an EV owner does, your vehicle gas mileage would need to be only 12 miles per gallon.  That's in the range of gas mileage of one of the most popular vehicles in Texas:  the Ford F-150.  So while Tesla owners may not appreciate the implied comparison, they'll be paying at least as much road tax as your typical pickup driver does, if not more.

 

Fairness is always a question when the subject of taxes come up, and depending on your political leanings, what is fair in taxation can look very different to different people.  Libertarians, for example, would turn all roads (at least major roads like highways) into turnpikes and make users pay for them per use.  This idea used to be on the impractical pie-in-the-sky shelf, but with RFID systems, computerized license-plate cameras, and allied technologies, there is no longer a major technical barrier to widespread implementation of this notion.  

 

The problem with it is that it would be highly unpopular, as well as unprecedented.  The first scream we'd hear would be from the trucking companies, whose vehicles bang up the roads a lot more than passenger cars do.  Of course, they are already paying a lot more in taxes than ordinary cars do.  A 2015 article said that even back then, the trucking industry in the U. S. paid $21.6 billion in state highway use taxes, and almost as much in federal highway taxes.  And there's a 12% federal excise tax on new trucks, which can add up to $30,000 to the price.  So they are not getting a free ride by any means. 

 

Unmentioned so far in this hypothetical libertarian ideal of paying road taxes per mile is the cost of administrating such a tax.  It costs something to gather the data needed:  those camera and flash bridges over tollroads, or even more intrusive technology such as checking into a car's computer via the Internet to find where and how far it's driven.  We quickly get into privacy concerns there, so perhaps it's just as well that the Texas legislature decided to pass a flat $200 registration fee rather than getting fancy and libertarian about it.

 

We are so used to large-scale infrastructure systems like the interstate highways being paid for by a combination of federal and state taxes, that we don't stop to consider alternatives that modern technical means could allow us to do.  The rather obscure economic and political system called distributism favors smallness over bigness and local control over centralized control.  Economist John C. Médaille points out that the current funding system for highways is a subsidy for suburbs and for industries that depend on long-distance trucking (think Walmart and groceries shipped across the country).  What should we do instead?  Says Médaille, "The freeways should be replaced by toll roads, roads capable of collecting their building, maintenance, operational, and replacement costs."  He estimates we could reduce the current national budget for transportation by at least half in this way. 

 

Of course, such a move probably won't happen in isolation, for all the reasons I gave above.  It would have to be part of a larger trend toward the de-centralization of society as a whole. 

 

In places such as China, and increasingly in the U. S. as well, technology is being used to extract information and money from large numbers of people and concentrate it in the hands of a few, whether those few are government leaders or business owners and operators. 

 

But as we have seen during the COVID epidemic, technology can also be used to return work to home, to enable small local businesses to establish international markets, and to connect people in the same geographic area together in ways that used to work only when people physically met as they walked to the town grocery store or post office.  I will not go so far as to say technology is neutral—it never is, completely—but just because powerful interests are using it for increasing centralization doesn't mean it always has to be that way.

 

In passing the annual $200 registration fee, Texas sought to redress an imbalance that new technology has caused.  As we've seen, the legislation has done a reasonably good job of that.  But the larger question of whether power and money, in the form of taxes, should be concentrated or decentralized has been left untouched by this move.  It will take something bigger than the popularity of Teslas to start a larger conversation about the role of technology in the centralization of power, and whether we want to sit back and let it continue, or to try reversing it. 

 

Sources:  The article "Texas EV Owners Hit With New $200 Registration Fee" appeared on the Forbes website at https://www.forbes.com/wheels/news/ev-registration-fees-texas/.  I also consulted articles at  https://www.reference.com/world-view/gas-mileage-ford-f-150

and https://www.ccjdigital.com/business/article/14933601/heres-how-much-trucking-paid-in-highway-user-taxes-in-2015.  John C. Médaille's Toward a Truly Free Market, from which the above quotation was taken, was published in 2010 by ISI Press.