Showing posts with label unintended consequences. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unintended consequences. Show all posts

Monday, August 05, 2024

Benevolent Spinoffs in Technology: Smartphones and the Deaf Population

 

At the town recreation center where my wife and I take exercise from time to time, one day we passed a man who was using American Sign Language (ASL).  That in itself is not too unusual in Central Texas, as there is a long-established Texas School for the Deaf in Austin, and as a result we have a higher-than-average concentration of deaf and hearing-impaired people in the area. 

 

What was unusual is that he was by himself, directing his gestures and facial expressions to his smartphone, propped on a chair next to him.  It never occurred to me until that moment that the video-call feature is a huge step forward for deaf individuals who use ASL.  As long as the person at the other end also knows ASL, there's no need for any intervening interpreters or translation functions:  just look and talk, and this guy was enthusiastically doing just that.

 

This was the vision of some Cornell researchers back in 2009, when older and slower 2-G phone systems were barely able to handle still images, let alone the 10-frame-per-second or so data rates needed to convey ASL efficiently.  Sheila Hemami, a professor of electrical and computer engineering, led a four-year effort to squeeze video of both hand gestures and facial expressions over the limited bandwidth then available.  By 2009, they were testing 25 prototype units with deaf individuals in the Seattle area, and hoped that their pioneering efforts would take hold and spread.  Of course, when wider bandwidths and videoconferencing came along, the problem almost solved itself.

 

Even back then, deaf people could send text messages, and in fact that is the only way they could use the telecommunications network for many decades.  Because most people have normal hearing, the big priority for deaf people is to communicate with a hearing person who has no knowledge of ASL.  With the advent of the telephone, the only way a deaf person could use it  at first was to sign to a hearing person, and ask the hearing person to make the phone call.  This works, but requires a resident hearing person to help you.

 

The next step came when a deaf physicist and amateur radio operator, a deaf orthodontist, and the grandson of the founder of Saks Fifth Avenue used some surplus teletype machines to demonstrate typewritten communications over ordinary phone lines.  This was in 1964, and in the succeeding decades, so-called TTY communication became a kind of standard for deaf people.  Service agencies sprang up who would read the TTY messages over the phone to hearing people so a deaf person could use their TTY to communicate with anyone who had a phone.  This was a great step forward, but still required the deaf person to invest heavily in a specialized set of equipment and hire a service agency to do something that hearing people could achieve with only a telephone.  Nevertheless, it became quite popular in the deaf community for all sorts of uses.  In a discussion thread on Reddit, a former TTY agent, as they were called, expressed amazement at how many deaf persons were calling sex chat rooms when he worked for the agency.  That would certainly pose an ethical dilemma for the agent, but common-carrier law back then would prevent the agency from turning down such business, I suppose.

 

When text messaging became feasible directly on one's mobile phone, deaf people seized on it eagerly, even back when one had to use a 10-key pad and multiple taps to encode messages.  Things got a lot easier with the advent of touchscreen phones and the bandwidth improvements that came along with 3-G and 4-G systems.  For communicating with hearing persons, there are now Video Relay Service (VRS) companies which employ ASL interpreters to relay messages from an ASL user to someone who doesn't understand ASL.  And with the advent of AI systems that are fluent in video images and sound as well as text, it is only a matter of time before someone develops an AI app that will at least supplement the work of a human ASL interpreter, and possibly become good enough to be used without human assistance at all. 

 

The use of videoconferencing for ASL was not the target application when smartphone developers set out to make video over phones possible.  But deaf people were the unintended beneficiaries nevertheless, and unintended uses turn out to be some of the more interesting byways in the history of technology.  Ronald Kline, a historian of technology at Cornell, has written extensively about how farmers adapted Model-T automobiles to do everything from plowing to grinding corn.  While Henry Ford wasn't planning on this, he was probably pleased if it meant more Fords were sold. 

 

This is one reason why engineering can never be an entirely theoretical arm-chair exercise.  Engineers have to get their prototype products out in the field where people they don't know will use them in ways that their designers can't imagine.  Sometimes these ways will cause harm, and that is why prototype testing with safety in mind is so important.  But almost as often, people will find beneficial uses that the developers never thought of, and what begins as a minor side use can become the main use after a while. 

 

The most prominent example of unintended uses I can think of came about with the development of the Internet itself.  While certain far-seeing individuals anticipated access to huge amounts of data by consumers (Vannevar Bush's 1945 "Memex" paper comes to mind), it seems that almost nobody prior to 1980 or so anticipated the huge increase in commercial applications of highly interconnected computer networks.  From early email, which was mainly a peculiar way of evading the long-distance telephone network used by a few physicists to exchange technical data at a distance, the Internet has now become a well-nigh-essential utility for billions of consumers, and sustains the economies of the world.  While it has its significant drawbacks (the maleficent influences of social media and Internet-based hacking come to mind), overall the Internet and its spawn have proved to be beneficial to humanity in myriad ways that its early developers and users never anticipated.

 

So I'm glad that members of the deaf community can now make phone calls to their deaf friends with as much ease and facility as their hearing counterparts can—and all without bothering anybody at the next table in the restaurant.

 

Sources:  The 2009 Cornell research is described at https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2009/12/researchers-create-cell-phones-sign-language.  I also referred to the websites https://nagish.com/post/how-to-use-telephone-if-deaf, about the history of TTY at https://www.smecc.org/tty___tdd_history_and_resources.htm, and discussions about the various technologies at the Reddit site https://www.reddit.com/r/CasualConversation/comments/ci1pbr/i_just_saw_a_deaf_person_having_a_phone/. 

Monday, March 25, 2024

GPS vs. Covered Bridges: Unintended Consequences

Every time a new technology becomes popular, effects happen that nobody anticipates—not the designers, not the firms selling the product, and not the users either.  A small but significant case in point was highlighted in a recent Associated Press piece describing the increased vulnerability of historic covered bridges in the U. S. to truck and RV drivers who blindly follow their GPS instructions, only to smash into the bridge superstructure.

 

Covered bridges were themselves a technical innovation.  According to the Wikipedia article on covered bridges, wooden structural members exposed to the weather, even if painted, will last only about 20 years before they need complete replacement.  In the 19th century, the European innovation of covering a bridge with walls and a roof spread to the U. S., and many thousands of them were built, mostly between 1825 and 1875.  Because they were usually built for local pedestrian, horse, and carriage traffic, the overhead clearance was typically about ten feet or less, well below the fourteen feet (4.3 meters) that is the U. S. interstate highway standard minimum clearance. 

 

Although most of the covered bridges in the U. S. are long gone, some communities have preserved them for historic and cultural reasons, and a few dozen are still used for vehicular traffic.  One such bridge stands outside Lyndon, Vermont.  The 140-year-old Miller's Run bridge provides a shortcut around the town of Lyndon, and many GPS-enabled smartphone programs such as Waze intended for passenger cars will route drivers through the bridge.  Despite several warning signs stating the low clearance of the bridge, at least 20 drivers of box trucks, vans, and RVs have hit the bridge in the last few years.  Sometimes only minor cosmetic damage results, but on one occasion a delivery truck hit the bridge supports.  That cost the town $100,000 and put the bridge out of commission for several months.

 

When the driver can be identified, the town can collect insurance money to pay for the damage, but many drivers just keep going, sometimes leaving air-conditioning units behind that are scraped off the top of campers.

 

Bill Caswell, who is president of the National Society for the Preservation of Covered Bridges, says this problem turns out to be a constant battle.  The only sure-fire solution is to build heavy steel height-limit barriers at each end.  But even when communities put up warning signs and flashing lights to inform drivers of the upcoming obstructions, many of them are still surprised when they hit the barriers.

 

Many of you may never have seen a covered bridge, and even fewer have tried to drive across one in a truck that's too tall for it.  But this problem is a good example of a widespread issue that philosopher and psychologist Iain McGilchrist has pointed out in his book The Master and His Emissary, and more briefly in a recent article in the journal of religion and public life First Things. 

 

McGilchrist is one of the world's leading experts in the differing functions of the left and right hemispheres of the brain.  His thesis defies easy summary, but basically, one can think of the two hemispheres as two people with complementary personalities working together as a team to accomplish mental tasks. 

 

The right hemisphere is focused outward.  It is the one that perceives the world and admits its complexity and mystery, in the sense of being partially but not completely understandable.  The right hemisphere helps us to appreciate art, poetry, and the best in human relationships.

 

The left hemisphere, on the other hand, tends to simplify and abstract things down to only the essentials needed to get something done.  It is the brain's bureaucrat, ignoring subtleties and ambiguities, and sticking heedlessly to a task long after the wider-ranging purposes of the task are forgotten.  The left hemisphere can't see the forest for the trees, and McGilchrist's cri de coeur these days is that once more (after similar paths trod by ancient Greece and Rome), we are letting left-brain thinking take over our civilization, and are in danger of falling into ruin just as those civilizations did. 

 

When someone driving a rented moving van for the first time tries to get through Lyndon, Vermont, if he or she is following right-brain thinking, the thing to do would be to drive through the quaint old town, stop in and have a meal, maybe, and stroll around the town common, appreciating the flavor of a historic location full of time-bound associations and resonances of the past. 

 

But if the driver is dominated by left-brain patterns, Lyndon is just an obstruction on the way to wherever the goal lies, and in following that fount of efficiency, the voice on the GPS-enabled phone, the driver turns away from the town and heads straight for the Miller's Run bridge.  Perhaps the driver observes the scenery—the trees, the street signs, the warning sign saying something about a bridge—but the left brain discards all of this as meaningless and useless fluff.  The main thing is to cover so many miles in so many hours and get to the goal on the map.  In this way, dozens of drivers have plowed straight into the bridge covering, wreaking various amounts of damage and propelling themselves off an idealized digital map into the real world of recalcitrant lumber, damaged vehicles, and auto insurance claims. 

 

Perhaps the town of Lyndon will finally decide enough is enough, and erect two sturdy steel arch barriers over the roadways approaching the bridge so that even GPS-hypnotized drivers can't cause any more damage.  But these barriers will stand as a mute and expensive testimony to the inability of modern humans to embrace the whole of their environment, instead of giving in to a tunnel-vision version of reality simplified to a creeping colored line on a map. 

 

Or maybe, just maybe, the world will heed the call of prophets such as McGilchrist and pull back from the brink of disaster that we seem to be teetering on.  If history is any guide, though, it will be hard to stop ourselves in time.  And this go-round, we may damage a lot more than a few bridges.

 

Sources:  The Associated Press article "Historic covered bridges are under threat by truck drivers relying on GPS meant for cars" by Lisa Rathke appeared on Mar. 20 at https://apnews.com/article/covered-bridges-gps-truckers-accidents-906e3379e07b20dbcdbe16e7cf5e5d6d.  I also referred to the Wikipedia article on covered bridges.  Iain McGilchrist's article "Resist the Machine Apocalypse" appeared in the March 2024 issue of First Things, and can be viewed at https://www.firstthings.com/article/2024/03/resist-the-machine-apocalypse.


Monday, September 25, 2023

Unintended Consequences: The California Electric Truck Mandate

 

If you own a trucking company that picks up shipments from California ports, you now have to deal with the consequences of a new law designed to reduce your carbon footprint.

 

Trucking is one of the vital ingredients in our infrastructure that virtually all parts of the economy rely on.  About two-fifths of all containerized imports to the U. S. come through one of California's twelve commercial ports.  According to a recent report in National Review, beginning January 1, any trucker doing "drayage" (the technical term for transporting stuff to or from a seaport) in California can only buy zero-emission vehicles, although they can hang on to their existing diesel fleet for a while.

 

Trucks don't last forever, however, and evidently the court of wisdom otherwise known as the California legislature decided this was the best way to get truckers used to the additional coming mandate that in 2035, all trucks entering California seaports and intermodal rail yards (where the containers are loaded onto trains) must be zero-emission types. 

 

The ostensible motivation for these laws is to reduce the emission of greenhouse gases, of course.  And careful analyses do show that over the lifetime of an electric vehicle, even if you include the fossil fuels used in the different types of manufacturing (electric versus internal-combustion) and in producing the electricity for the vehicle, less carbon dioxide results from using electric vehicles.  That's the intended consequence, and unless the law is later modified, it will be achieved.

 

But the devil is in the details, and some truckers interviewed about the mandate pointed out several unintended consequences that may follow from these laws.  For one thing, the number of electric trucks in California will have to go from about 300, where it is today, to around 500,000, and some way will have to be found to charge all those trucks, and to keep them running farther than the alleged 60 miles that the California regulators said was the typical drayage daily mileage.  A lot of truckers drive a lot farther than that every day, and if you add several hours a day to charge the trucks, it turns a normal workday into a 20-hour day. 

 

And then there's the cost.  Even if you can find a zero-emission truck that will do the job, it will cost three or four times what a diesel vehicle costs.  And one trucker asked what bank will finance such a purchase if you can't show where you're going to charge it and how you will work out a schedule that will let you stay in business. 

 

So if California doubles down on enforcement, we can anticipate something like a gradual strangling of commerce flowing through its ports as the few truckers who manage to jump through the hoops of regulation are all that's left.  And maybe that was what the lawmakers really wanted anyway.  If the idealist dream of a zero-emission society were to come to pass in the next couple of years, millions would die of starvation and cold, and those few who are left would be reduced to living a life that would be familiar to a denizen of 1880. 

 

At the very least, essentially shutting down 40% of containerized imports to the U. S. would cause massive supply-chain disruptions that would make what happened during COVID look like a hiccup.  If you say no one would let things get that bad, well, we did let things get that bad during COVID, and it can happen again.

 

I recently came across a true story that should become the paradigm cautionary tale for those who close their eyes to the unintended consequences of legislation. 

 

In England in the mid-1800s, dogs were quite commonly used for transportation.  Poor people who couldn't afford a horse and wagon to carry their goods to market could nevertheless use a dog and a "dog-cart" (not to be confused with the horse-drawn carriage referred to in Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes tales).  But in 1841, the recently founded Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA) successfully lobbied to pass a law prohibiting the use of dogs for transportation.  In urging this measure, the SPCA cited a few highly publicized instances of cruelty to transport dogs, although it appears that many if not most of the dogs were well-treated.  For good measure, a dog tax was also passed around the same time, further discouraging the use of dogs for business purposes.

 

I can't be positive, but I suspect that the SPCA members were largely upper-class types who, if they thought ahead at all, imagined all the dogs formerly used for transport would revert to being beloved pets.  Think again.  According to Stanley Coren, a dog psychologist and historian, when the law took effect it led to something close to a dog holocaust:  

 

"Dreadful massacres of dogs took place all over England when they could no longer legally be used for cartage but were now taxable.  In Birmingham, more than a thousand were slaughtered, and similar carnage took place in Liverpool.  In Cambridge, the streets were littered with dead dogs.  Because these bodies were becoming a health hazard, the high constable of Cambridge arranged a mass burial of four hundred dogs."

 

So much for good intentions.  The SPCA survived this debacle somehow, and so did the use of dogs for transportation in other parts of the world, but no longer in England.

 

No one can be certain of exactly what will happen if California enforces their zero-emission truck mandate.  But they are meddling with a piece of infrastructure that is crucial to the entire U. S. economy, and if the law has the unintended consequence of disrupting commerce in ways that harm millions of U. S. citizens, those harms should be weighed against whatever essentially unmeasurable good that may eventually come a century or so after California's greenhouse-gas emissions go down by a few percent as a result of this law.  In my view, the law will do a lot more harm than good, and most of the California truckers think so too.

 

Sources:  National Review's website carried the article "California EV Rules 'Totally Impractical,' Truckers Say; Might as Well 'Build a Spaceship and Go to Mars'" at https://www.nationalreview.com/news/california-ev-rules-totally-impractical-truckers-say-may-as-well-build-a-spaceship-and-go-to-mars/.  I also referred to https://historum.com/t/dog-carts-as-a-form-of-transport.196441/, https://www.carbonbrief.org/factcheck-how-electric-vehicles-help-to-tackle-climate-change/, and Stanley Coren's The Intelligence of Dogs:  Canine Consciousness and Capabilities (Macmillan, 1994), pp. 155-156.