Showing posts with label Apollo 13. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Apollo 13. Show all posts

Monday, October 20, 2025

Shackleton's Flawed Ship

 

Ernest Shackleton (1874-1922) almost reached the South Pole in 1909, although he lost the title of being first to get there to Roald Amundsen, who achieved that record in 1911.  Shackleton then set his sights on being the first to traverse Antarctica from one side to the other, and for that project purchased the wooden excursion ship Endurance.  He embarked on his grandly-named "Imperial Trans-Antarctic Expedition" on Dec. 5, 1914 from the small island near the tip of South America called South Georgia, intending to land at Vahsel Vay in the Weddell Sea, reach the South Pole, and cross to the other side with the aid of a second provisions-laying party.

 

It was a complicated and ambitious undertaking.  Endurance got stuck in the ice in mid-January after nearly reaching Vahsel Bay, and Shackleton decided to wait on board the ship until the following spring, nine months later.  Meanwhile, over the Antarctic winter, the drifting ice slowly moved the ship several hundred miles northwest until the following October, when the spring thaws began to exert extreme pressure on the hull.

 

On October 24, the hull broke, water rushed in, and Shackleton ordered the ship abandoned.  The crew transferred to camps on the ice, and the ship finally sank on Nov. 21, 1915.  This began a series of adventures for Shackleton and his men which would be too long to recite here, but eventually they made it back to something like civilization in August of 1916.

 

Now we fast-forward to 2022, when an equally daring expedition called Endurance22 found Endurance below 3000 meters of water (9900 feet) and did extensive photographic documentation of the wreck, which by international agreement will remain undisturbed. 

The details of what they found about why the Endurance sank are described in a recent UPI report by Stephen Feller.

 

After the wreck was found, researcher Jukka Tuhkuri and his colleagues of Aalto University in Finland conducted an investigation into why Endurance sank.  Even as long ago as the 1910s, shipwrights knew how to construct ships that would withstand the extreme pressures exerted by ice in the Antarctic.  But as their analysis of documents such as ship's plans, diaries, and other sources indicated, Endurance wasn't built that way.

 

On the lowest deck, which contained the boilers and steam engine, there was only one beam that crossed the entire ship from one side to the other.  Ships designed to withstand the compressive forces of ice normally had several such beams spaced along the length of the ship to resist the ice, which otherwise will crack a hull like someone squeezing an eggshell too hard.  But that is apparently what happened to Endurance.  Although it lasted nearly a year stuck in the ice, the stresses caused by the following spring's thaw exceeded its capacity to resist them, and it cracked and sank.

 

According to Tukhuri, Shackleton was aware that the ship he bought was built only for polar excursions and not what amounted to ice-breaking duty.  The researchers even found a letter written by Shackleton, mentioning that he had recommended adding additional internal hull-bracing beams for another polar exploration ship that had got stuck in ice but didn't get crushed.  Tukhuri speculates that Shackleton was in a hurry and bought the ship knowing it wasn't sufficiently braced, but hoping that he could avoid putting it in a situation where the missing beams wouldn't be needed.  Unfortunately, that's not what happened.

 

Although he wasn't an engineer, Shackleton was making engineering decisions as he prepared for his grand expedition.  Engineering is the application of limited resources to a technical problem, and that's exactly what Shackleton was doing.  Sometimes the time and expense required to prevent a somewhat unlikely event from happening simply isn't available.  Rather than abort the whole project, Shackleton decided to go ahead, trusting in his navigation skills and previous Antarctic experience to avoid disaster.  But his gamble with the missing beams didn't pay off, and he had to rely even more than he expected to on his survival skills to get him and his crew off the ice and back to civilization.

 

Shackleton's ill-fated expedition reminds me of the Apollo 13 near-disaster, in which three astronauts were stranded in space on their way to the moon in 1970 by an oxygen tank that exploded when some damaged insulation resulted in an internal fire.  The resulting damage led to a long series of improvised solutions to unexpected problems, which the astronauts carried out in coordination with the extensive NASA support staff on the ground.  Like Shackleton, the Apollo 13 team never reached their goal, but simply getting back to civilization after the accident was a bigger triumph than even landing on the moon again. 

 

Apollo 13's accident was caused by a manufacturing flaw, not a design flaw.  Still, the improvisation and backup systems used to rescue the mission were similar to what Shackleton used in getting his crew back safely. 

 

Most of us will never go on expeditions to unexplored lands or planets.  But the civilizational urge is still there, which is why several countries continue to plan both manned and unmanned expeditions to the Moon, Mars, and even farther. 

 

If and when these plans come to fruition, we can count on several things.  One is that not everything will go according to plan.  When engineers encounter a novel situation, despite all the advance information they can gather about it in advance, there is always something unexpected.  Sometimes it's just a matter for curiosity, but other times it can be a matter of life and death. 

 

Another thing is that good engineering practice and planning can provide enough backup resources to allow clever individuals to create a survival plan even in the face of a major disaster.  Losing the Endurance was a big setback, but Shackleton had packed enough auxiliary supplies in the form of food, shelter, and other necessaries, so that he and his crew could perform the extraordinary feat of extracting themselves from what must have looked like certain death at times.  And the ingenuity of NASA engineers combined with the intrepid actions of the Apollo 13 crew to get them safely home, despite major damage to the Service Module that contained the oxygen tank which blew up.

 

Companies such as SpaceX are now leading the way into space, and it remains to be seen how well they balance the goals of achieving a mission first at any cost, including death, versus proceeding more slowly with more backup systems and more thoughtful engineering.  So far, none of the commercial space enterprises has ever lost a life in space.  Let's hope it stays that way as long as possible.

 

Sources:  The article "Shackleton's sunken polar ship may have been weaker than thought" by Stephen Feller was published on the UPI website on Oct. 6, 2025 at https://www.upi.com/Science_News/2025/10/06/shackleton-endurance-ship-crushed-in-ice/9321759774913/.  The Endurance22 website is at https://endurance22.org/.  I also referred to the Wikipedia articles on Apollo 13,  Ernest Shackleton, and Endurance. 

Monday, August 06, 2012

Curiosity Kills the Skeptics—So Far


As you know by now if you have the slightest interest in the U. S. space program—and maybe even if you don’t—the unmanned Mars exploration craft called Curiosity landed successfully last night, a little after midnight Central Daylight Time.  This represents both a triumph for those who have advocated unmanned automated space exploration as the way to go, and the advent of a new NASA that is willing to relax and do a little showbiz of its own.

The Curiosity program is not without its critics.  Originally planned to cost $1.6 billion, which as major space probes go is not cheap but orders of magnitude less than manned flight, the launch date was delayed by two years because of technical problems and the final cost so far is $2.5 billion.  And as with any novel space venture, there was always a significant chance that the whole thing would turn into useless space junk.

But there’s a lot of grateful engineers at NASA this morning.  The elaborate sequence of rocket deceleration, ablation of a heat shield as the craft entered the thin Martian atmosphere, deployment of a parachute, and ignition of “hover” rockets to suspend the main body of the craft a hundred feet or so above the surface while the Curiosity vehicle itself was lowered on a cable, all worked apparently without flaw.  Cheers greeted the first grainy black-and-white image that the craft sent from the Martian surface.

Payoff will be a while in coming.  For the first month or so, engineers will just be checking out all the systems before issuing orders to drive anywhere.  But there are some very sophisticated instruments on board, including lasers to vaporize rock samples, a kind of low-power microscope, and a Russian neutron-based instrument that can search for hydrogen up to three meters deep in the soil.  The main goal of the whole project is to search for signs of present (or former) life on the planet.

I am not in the habit of making prognostications, but as various space probes have shown that interplanetary space is a more permeable region than we formerly believed, it would not surprise me to learn that Curiosity eventually finds some pretty uncontrovertible evidence of organically-produced stuff up there.  This would raise a lot more questions than it answers, of course, ranging from which came first, life on Mars or life on Earth? to whether life just naturally shows up under the right conditions, or whether it is a special and perhaps unique feature of Earth.  But we will just have to wait a few months to see about that.

This blog has carried more than its share of criticisms of NASA, but criticizing NASA is like saying “Texas is hot”—it’s not just one organization in one building.  Some parts of NASA are indeed dysfunctional, but the division responsible for the Curiosity mission has so far demonstrated their competence in the best possible way:  by succeeding in an ambitious and potentially fruitful scientific mission.

And perhaps because of the younger mix of engineers in this team, the way they have chosen to present the project to the public has a very different feel than what I am used to from NASA.  The old style is represented well in the film Apollo 13, where scenes of the NASA control room were filled with pudgy white-shirted chain-smoking engineers in ties, all male.  Official pronouncements and publicity were couched in stuffy NASA-speak that required interpretation to be understood by ordinary human beings.

But the material coming from the Curiosity team is very different. In a photo of the Curiosity control room just after the landing that accompanied the New York Times announcement, the predominant color was blue—evidently a kind of blue tee-shirt was the uniform of the day.  But there are no ties and no smoking visible, and at least a few women with responsibilities equal to those of the men are shown hugging the men.  It’s quite a contrast to the old days, and also shows up in the official Curiosity website, which seems to be aimed at about thirteen-year-olds.  Curiosity itself is quoted as talking about its mission:  “What’s My Mission?” is one menu item—and it has sent Twitter feeds such as “FYI, I aim to send bigger, color pictures from Mars later this week once I've got my head up & Mastcam active #MSL.”  (The overall project is known by its full name, the Mars Science Laboratory, or MSL for short, while the lander itself is called Curiosity.)  As if that wasn’t unbent enough, NASA reportedly issued a short documentary using simulated scenes of the landing, but emphasizing the risky nature of the process and using Hollywood-style effects for maximum dramatic impact.

Hey, if you’ve got it, flaunt it.  Following a series of failures in the first decade of the 21st century, NASA’s public image got pretty tarnished, but at least for the unmanned missions such as the MSL, it looks like their confidence has returned.  We will always have people around who say things like “For that $2.5 billion we could have fed X million starving people.”  This is always true, but I think the real reason for the MSL is encapsulated nicely in the name of the rover:  Curiosity.  This project represents a fairly unusual resurgence in public life these days of science for its own sake, unbuttressed by wire-drawn arguments that the work will really lead to practical applications such as better toasters, or some such thing.  Modern science since the days of Sir Francis Bacon has always been in tension between pure abstract curiosity on the one hand, and commercially profitable applications on the other hand.  There never was a time when the two poles were not present, but the practical pole has dominated to a greater extent than historically has been the case in the last few decades.  Perhaps Curiosity will inspire through its kid-friendly publicity a new generation of scientists who want to do science, not because it will make them more bucks, but simply because they want to know.

Sources:  The New York Times report on the landing of Curiosity appeared at  http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/06/science/space/curiosity-rover-lands-safely-on-mars.html.  I also used material from the NASA website’s fact sheet at http://mars.jpl.nasa.gov/msl/news/pdfs/MSL_Fact_Sheet.pdf.