Near-universal consensus about anything is rare in ethics. But I think you could get most people to agree
on an answer to the question, "Was the invention of the Nazi gas chambers
a good invention?" In the Auschwitz
concentration camp operated by Nazi Germany during World War II, an estimated
1.1 million people died, most of them Jews, and scientifically-designed gas
chambers were used to kill many of them.
Those gas chambers represent a nadir in the history of engineering: designed by a corrupt, malevolent government for
industrial-scale executions of people who died in them only because they ran
afoul of Hitler's regime.
Ah, but what if those wanting to try out a gas chamber are not
compelled, but have made the decision of their own free will? And have even passed an online test
certifying that they are of "sound mind"? And have read a fancy advertising brochure
promising "death with style and elegance"? Just climb into the Death Pod—which looks
like what you might get if you asked Apple to design a body-length chest-style
freezer—lie down, make yourself comfortable, and push the button. The software does all the rest. Allegedly, the user will experience first
"euphoria" as the oxygen level decreases, then pass out into the
Great Beyond. Since liquid nitrogen is
involved, it's not clear whether the corpse is flash-frozen after death or if
that's just a convenient way to get a supply of suffocating nitrogen. But after you're dead, it really doesn't
matter.
The inventor of the Death Pod is Philip Nitschke, a resident of
the Netherlands who has been working on self-operated suicide machines since at
least the 1990s. I won't remark on the
similarity of Mr. Nitschke's name to the philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche,
except to say that they seem to share a pessimistic view of life that partakes
of what some call the culture of death.
The alleged problem that the Death Pod addresses is the tiresome
necessity of involving medical personnel, or worse yet, rolling your own
method, in one's decision to commit suicide. The writer and wit Dorothy Parker portrayed
the difficulties facing someone who has reached the decision to do herself in
with this grim little poem, titled "Résumé:"
Razors pain
you,
Rivers are
damp,
Acids stain
you,
And drugs cause
cramp.
Guns aren't lawful,
Nooses give,
Gas smells
awful,
You might as
well live.
But Parker, who died in 1967 of mostly natural causes, didn't live to see how the Death
Pod could solve all these problems in one stroke.
In a development that I am sure will be noted by future
historians (assuming there are any left), the idea of legalizing suicide has
spread around the world in recent decades.
In the Netherlands, Germany, Canada, and some U. S. states, both euthanasia
(mercy killing by physicians) and suicide are legal, and organizations such as
Nitschke's "Exit International" promote the idea that killing
yourself should be—well, it's hard to say what they think it should be. Socially acceptable? More often considered as an option to be
chosen when facing problems? Quick,
easy, and convenient, like the tag line to countless other advertisements for
products that let you become more of the ideal autonomous self that modern
culture seems to be encouraging us to be?
All of these things and more.
As far as I
can tell, nobody has actually died in a Death Pod yet. Nitschke enlisted the help of an industrial
designer in creating a full-scale model that people visiting it on display in
Venice, Italy can try on for size.
There's a photo of a gal lying underneath the clear plastic canopy of
the thing, holding a bunch of lilies and grinning. Death can be funny if you can open up the canopy
and get out afterwards. But that won't
be an option once Nitzschke finishes his design and publishes 3-D printing
instructions for the entire system.
This whole
thing may be nothing more than a publicity stunt, as the news reports about it
say that Nitschke isn't planning to make and sell the device himself,
apparently concerned that he might get in trouble with a government which
doesn't look favorably on people selling products that are not only likely to
kill their owners, but almost guaranteed to.
Instead, the suicidal customer is expected to download the plans, 3-D
print the device somewhere (good luck finding a printer large enough to handle
a coffin-size plastic box capable of holding the weight of the average human),
and hook it up to liquid nitrogen that you get at your handy local
liquid-nitrogen convenience store.
Technically,
this scenario doesn't make much sense, and it sounds like there's some important
ingredients missing. For example, a
third party (Nitzsche doesn't say who) has to be involved to give the user an
access code to get into the thing, presumably ensuring that the user has passed
an online test verifying that they are of sound mind. But the definition of "sound mind"
must be pretty skewed. Public health
officials tend to treat suicidal tendencies as aberrant behavior, not evidence
of a sound mind.
There are so many things wrong with this idea that I could write several
columns about it, but I will close with this thought, which readers not
believing in the supernatural can skip.
Ever since the Fall in the Garden of Eden, humanity has been in a battle
that is primarily waged in the spiritual realm, between God and his angels and
the Devil and his angels. The Devil
would like nothing better than to kill off humanity, which he finds offensive
in the highest degree. So he likes to
portray death as attractive, even as stylish and elegant, in order to achieve
his purposes, which are to kill, steal, and destroy. Philip Nitschke is an unwitting servant of
the Devil when he goes around promoting attractive means of killing oneself. The Devil, a liar from the beginning, likes
to fool us with the illusion that we are autonomous individuals who can freely
choose what to be or how to end our lives, with no adverse consequences.
The Death Pod is just one of the latest of his tricks. But somehow the product's execution (pardon
the expression) doesn't sound like it will live up to the hype its creator has
generated, and I for one hope it doesn't.
Sources: I first heard
about the Death Pod on the Patrick Madrid Show carried by the Catholic radio
network Relevant Radio. I also referred
to reports on it at the websites https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/euthanasia-expert-invents-death-pod-with-die-button-that-kills-victims-within-minutes
and https://www.businessinsider.co.za/a-pro-euthanasia-humanist-has-invented-a-death-pod-to-help-patients-pass-on-peacefully-without-the-need-to-involve-a-medical-professional-2019-5.
No comments:
Post a Comment